Explainers › Patreon for rigid heddle weaving creators

Patreon for rigid heddle weaving creators: the rigid heddle as combined heddle and beater, the two-shed plain weave limit, direct versus indirect warping, sett versus dent spacing, the pick-up stick, selvedge bubble technique, and the Apple Tax in 2026

2026-08-22 · ~5,400 words

Rigid heddle weaving tutorial videos demonstrate the hand sequence — how to thread the heddle, how to pass the shuttle, how to beat. What they cannot demonstrate is the mechanical logic beneath those motions: why the heddle couples sett to beat force in a way the floor loom does not, why the loom cannot produce pattern weaves without a pick-up stick, how the cross built during warping board warping determines thread order in the finished cloth, or why the selvedge management technique on a rigid heddle loom is physically different from floor loom practice. These properties are structural and invisible to a camera showing hand motion. A patron who understands the motion but not the mechanics cannot diagnose why their sett is wrong, why their pattern shed failed, or why their selvedges are pulling in. This post documents the mechanical layer.

The rigid heddle as combined heddle and beater

On a floor loom, the heddle and the beater are two separate mechanical components that operate independently. The heddle frames (shafts) hold individual heddle wires or string heddles through which the warp threads are threaded; raising or lowering a shaft group creates the shed. The beater is a separate swinging frame that holds a reed — a comb of closely-spaced metal or plastic dents through which the warp threads also pass, maintaining their spacing. After the weft shuttle passes through the shed, the weaver swings the beater forward to pack the weft against the fell of the cloth, then swings it back before changing sheds. Because they are mechanically independent, a floor loom weaver can adjust beat force by changing the beater swing angle and momentum without changing the sett; can change the reed to alter the warp spacing without re-threading the shafts; and can adjust the number of shafts (and therefore the pattern complexity) independent of the reed spacing.

On a rigid heddle loom, a single physical object does both jobs. The rigid heddle is a flat frame, typically made from plastic or wood, with alternating slots and holes across its full width. The holes are drilled through the solid material of the heddle — each hole is a fixed point through which one warp thread passes. The slots are open notches, cut from the top or bottom of the heddle frame between adjacent holes — each slot holds one warp thread in a notch that allows the thread to move up or down relative to the heddle.

When the heddle is raised by holding its frame and lifting upward, all slot threads — which sit freely in their notches — rise with the heddle frame. All hole threads — which pass through fixed holes — stay at the level of the hole (approximately the neutral heddle position) and cannot rise. This creates the up-shed: a triangular opening between the raised slot threads above and the stationary hole threads below, through which the weft shuttle passes. When the heddle is lowered, slot threads drop with the frame and hole threads stay at their fixed positions, creating the down-shed with slot threads below and hole threads above. After each weft pass, the weaver moves the heddle to a neutral horizontal position and pushes the heddle frame forward toward the fell. The frame itself packs the weft — this is the beating action. The rigid heddle is both the heddle and the beater in one tool.

The coupling consequence: the heddle's dent spacing — the number of slot-hole pairs per inch across the heddle width — is fixed at manufacture and determines the warp sett. A 10-dent rigid heddle has 10 slot-hole pairs per inch, and at standard threading (one thread per slot, one thread per hole) produces a fixed sett that cannot be adjusted without changing the heddle or changing the threading density. The beat force is similarly constrained by the heddle mass and the weaver's push angle — fine-tuning beat weight the way a floor loom weaver adjusts the beater's hanging weight or swing arc is not possible on a rigid heddle loom.

This is a design tradeoff, not a defect. The coupling makes the loom mechanically simple, inexpensive, and portable. The tradeoff is that project planning must work within the available heddle dent options rather than treating sett as a free variable. A Patreon pattern that specifies "use any loom" without specifying the heddle dent count and threading density will produce unpredictable results on a rigid heddle loom, because the patron's heddle determines the sett rather than the pattern specifying a sett and the patron choosing the heddle to match.

The two sheds and the plain weave limit

The rigid heddle loom produces exactly two shed positions: up-shed (heddle raised, slot threads above hole threads) and down-shed (heddle lowered, slot threads below hole threads). These are the only two positions the heddle mechanism can create. Alternating up-shed and down-shed picks — one weft pass through the up-shed, one through the down-shed, repeating — produces plain weave, also called tabby.

In plain weave, every warp thread alternates over one weft pick and under the next across the full width of the cloth. Slot threads go over one pick and under the next; hole threads go under the same pick that slot threads go over, and over the next. Together, the full warp produces the standard over-one-under-one interlacing that is plain weave. It is the simplest woven structure and requires exactly two alternating sheds. The rigid heddle provides exactly two alternating sheds.

The loom cannot produce a third shed — a position where some but not all slot threads are raised, or where some hole threads are differentiated from others — through heddle movement alone. There is no intermediate heddle position that splits the slot-thread group or the hole-thread group into sub-groups. This is the structural ceiling of the loom at its plain operation: plain weave, full stop.

Any pattern structure beyond plain weave requires a mechanism outside the heddle. The standard mechanism is the pick-up stick. Some rigid heddle looms accept a second heddle (mounted either in front of or behind the primary heddle) that creates additional shed positions when operated in combination with the primary heddle. But the two-shed ceiling is inherent to the single-heddle loom, and understanding it is foundational: a rigid heddle patron who expects to weave a floor loom twill pattern directly on their rigid heddle loom is working from a false premise, and no amount of instruction on hand technique will bridge the gap.

Direct warping versus indirect warping

Warping is the process of loading warp threads onto the loom in the correct order, at the correct length, and at the correct tension. On a rigid heddle loom, two methods accomplish this: direct warping and indirect warping.

Direct warping winds the warp threads directly onto the loom without using a separate warping device. The process begins with a warping peg or hook, which is typically clamped to a table or mounted on a wall at a measured distance from the front apron rod of the loom. The warp yarn is tied to the front apron rod, threaded through a slot in the heddle, carried across to the warping peg, wrapped around the peg, returned to the heddle, threaded through the next slot (passing from the other side), and wound around the back beam. This back-and-forth path is repeated across the full warp width. Because threads pass through slots during winding, the slot threads are loaded first; after all slots are filled, the weaver uses a threading hook to pull every other thread (the threads that cross between slot groups at the back of the heddle) through the heddle holes.

Direct warping advantages: it is fast, requires no additional equipment beyond the peg, and a beginner can complete a simple project warp in 20–30 minutes. The limitations are significant for longer projects. The warp length is bounded by the distance from the loom's front apron rod to the warping peg — for most in-home setups this is 1.5 to 3 yards. Projects requiring longer warps (complex yardage, multiple project repeats on one warp) cannot be direct-warped at these distances without complex peg arrangements. Additionally, the threading order is determined by the winding order and cannot be rearranged after the warp is on the loom.

Indirect warping builds the warp on a separate warping board or warping pegs before transferring it to the loom. The warping board has multiple pegs arranged so that the yarn path from one end to the other traces the full desired warp length. The yarn is wound from peg to peg repeatedly — each circuit contributes one thread to the warp width. At the cross pegs (the two outermost pegs at one end of the board), the thread alternates: outward pass goes over the first cross peg and under the second; return pass goes under the first and over the second. This alternation creates the cross: a point in the warp chain where consecutive threads pass each other in an over-under sequence that preserves thread order.

The cross is the critical element of indirect warping. It records which thread is thread 1, which is thread 2, and so on. Without the cross, the threads of the warp chain are an undifferentiated bundle; when a thread is pulled from the bundle to be threaded through the heddle, any thread might be thread 1. With the cross intact and secured with lease sticks (two flat sticks inserted on either side of the cross and tied together at their ends to prevent the cross from collapsing), the threads can be threaded through the heddle in sequence — first thread from one side of the cross, then the first thread from the other side, alternating — and the order is preserved.

Warp length planning differs between methods. Direct warping: the usable warp length is approximately 2× the peg-to-loom distance (thread travels to the peg and returns). Indirect warping: the warp length is set by the warping board path and can be made as long as needed by routing through additional pegs or winding the board multiple times. For project planning, total warp length must account for: woven length target, plus loom waste at both ends (the warp is tied onto the front and back apron rods and those sections cannot be woven — typically 9–12 inches at each end), plus take-up (plain weave warp take-up is typically 10–15% of woven length, meaning a warp must be 10–15% longer than the target woven length to produce the target after take-up), plus any sampling or hem allowance. A 36-inch-woven scarf at 12% take-up needs 36 ÷ 0.88 ≈ 41 inches of woven warp, plus 20 inches of loom waste, plus any sampling allocation.

Sett in ends per inch versus heddle dent spacing

Sett is the number of warp ends per inch in the set warp, measured across the warp width between the selvedges. It determines how densely the warp threads are spaced and, in combination with weft sett (picks per inch), determines the weave structure balance. Heddle dent spacing is the number of slot-hole pairs per inch in the rigid heddle. They describe related but distinct measurements, and using them interchangeably produces specification errors.

Consider a 10-dent rigid heddle: it has 10 slots per inch and 10 holes per inch, for 20 individual thread openings per inch. At standard threading — one thread per slot and one thread per hole — this heddle holds 20 warp ends per inch: 10 slot threads and 10 hole threads. The sett at standard threading is 20 epi, not 10 epi. The heddle is named by its dent count (10-dent) but the sett at standard threading is double the dent count.

The same 10-dent heddle can produce different setts by varying threading density. At half-sett threading — every other slot and hole filled, every other slot and hole empty — the sett is 10 epi. At double-sett threading — two threads per slot and two threads per hole — the sett is 40 epi (4 threads per dent × 10 dents per inch). At mixed threading (two threads per slot, one per hole) the sett is 30 epi.

Choosing the correct sett for a yarn requires measuring the yarn's wraps per inch (WPI): wrap the yarn snugly around a ruler for one inch without overlapping, count the wraps. For a balanced plain weave (warp and weft equally visible), sett ≈ WPI ÷ 2. For a warp-dominant fabric (warp threads visible, weft hidden), sett ≈ WPI × 0.6–0.7. For a weft-dominant fabric (weft visible, warp hidden, as in tapestry), sett ≈ WPI × 0.3–0.4.

A yarn with 20 WPI needs approximately 10 epi for balanced plain weave. The correct heddle configuration: a 10-dent heddle at half-sett threading (every other opening filled). A yarn with 16 WPI needs approximately 8 epi — but a 10-dent heddle cannot produce 8 epi at any standard threading option (10, 20, 5, 40 epi are the options). This yarn requires either a different heddle (an 8-dent heddle at standard threading produces approximately 8 epi for warp-dominant or a 16-dent heddle at half threading) or an acceptance that the sett will be slightly off the calculated balanced point.

For Patreon pattern documentation: publish both the heddle dent count and the threading density as separate specifications. A pattern stating "10-dent heddle, one thread per slot, one per hole" is unambiguous. A pattern stating "use a 10-dent heddle" is ambiguous by a factor of 4 in sett (5, 10, 20, or 40 epi all use a 10-dent heddle). Additionally, note that two threads in the same slot weave as a unit — they both rise and both fall together when the heddle moves — so double-slot threading is not the same weave structure as the equivalent single-thread sett.

The pick-up stick and pattern sheds beyond plain weave

The pick-up stick is a flat, smooth wooden or acrylic stick, typically 18–24 inches long for a standard rigid heddle loom. It creates a third shed by selectively differentiating within the slot-thread group — lifting some slot threads while leaving others down — which the heddle mechanism cannot do.

The setup process begins with the heddle in the down-shed position (heddle lowered, slot threads below hole threads). In this position, the slot threads are accessible in the warp between the heddle and the back beam. The weaver inserts the pick-up stick by passing it from selvedge to selvedge through the warp, going over selected slot threads and under others, following the intended pattern. Hole threads are not picked; the stick passes either over or under slot threads only. Once the entire pick-up sequence is set across the full warp width, the stick is turned flat and slid toward the back beam, where it rests stored in the warp without disturbing the slot threads.

To weave a pattern pick: with the heddle in the down-shed position, slide the pick-up stick forward toward the heddle. Turn the pick-up stick on its edge by rotating it 90 degrees so its thin dimension faces up. The slot threads that were over the stick when it was flat are now lifted by the stick's edge standing upright. Slot threads that were under the stick remain down. Hole threads remain at the neutral heddle position. The three-group differentiation creates the pick-up shed: an opening between the lifted slot threads above, the hole threads in the middle, and the dropped slot threads below. The weft passes through the pick-up shed. After the pick, the stick is returned to the flat position and slid back toward the back beam.

The pattern then alternates between pick-up sheds and plain weave sheds (up-shed or down-shed) in whatever sequence the weave structure requires. Huck lace, the most commonly taught rigid heddle pick-up structure, uses a repeating sequence of: pick-up shed, up-shed, reversed pick-up (the inverse of the original pick-up: the slots that were up in the first pick-up are now down, and vice versa), down-shed. This four-pick repeat creates pairs of weft floats at the picked-up positions, separated by plain weave picks that anchor the floats and create the lace windows.

Pick-up stick pattern documentation must specify: (1) the pick-up sequence from selvedge to selvedge, identifying which slot-thread positions are over the stick and which are under; (2) which pick positions in the sequence use the pick-up shed and which use plain weave sheds; (3) whether the pattern uses one pick-up configuration across the whole project or whether the pick-up sequence changes between pattern repeats. A pick-up diagram — a grid where rows represent picks and columns represent slot-thread positions, with marks indicating which slots are over the stick — is the clearest documentation format and cannot be replaced by prose description for anything more complex than a 2–3 slot repeat.

Pick-up stick patterns cannot be converted from floor loom threading drafts without recalculation. A floor loom draft specifies which shaft is raised at each pick; the pattern it produces depends on the threading (which shaft each thread is on). Converting to a rigid heddle pick-up requires knowing which threads are slot threads and which are hole threads, then determining which slots must be in the pick-up sequence at each pick to produce the same interlacing — a calculation that depends on the entire threading sequence. Rigid heddle patterns should provide pick-up diagrams in rigid heddle format, not floor loom draft notation.

Selvedge management: the bubble technique

On a floor loom, selvedge management typically uses a temple: a stretcher tool with toothed ends that hooks into the outermost warp loops at the fell and holds the cloth at full warp width. The temple compensates for the weft's tendency to draw the selvedges inward as the weft thread shortens from its angled entry path to its beaten position.

On a rigid heddle loom, a temple is not used for the primary selvedge management function. The heddle physically occupies the warp at all times — it holds the slot and hole threads in their dent positions across the full heddle width. The outermost slot threads and hole threads at each selvedge are held by the heddle at the fixed dent spacing, and cannot migrate inward the way they can on a floor loom with a freely-hanging beater. The heddle's presence mechanically maintains the warp width.

What the heddle does not control is the amount of weft thread between the selvedge thread and the point where the shuttle exits the shed. When the weft is passed through the shed and the shuttle exits at the right selvedge (for a right-to-left pass), the weft thread traces the straight-line distance from the left selvedge thread to the right selvedge thread. If the weft is pulled taut immediately after the shuttle exits, shortening the weft to the straight-line distance, the weft lacks sufficient length to undulate over and under each warp thread during beating.

When the heddle beats, it presses each warp thread against the weft, causing a slight vertical displacement — over-threads push the weft down; under-threads push the weft up. These vertical displacements require the weft to be longer than the straight-line warp width by the cumulative displacement amount. A warp with 10 warp threads per inch over 12 inches has 120 warp threads; each crossing requires approximately the yarn-diameter distance in extra length. If the weft is at exactly the straight-line width, it borrows the needed length from the selvedge threads, pulling them inward. Over many picks, this produces selvedges that draw progressively inward.

The bubble technique provides the extra length before beating. After passing the weft shuttle through the shed and before returning the heddle to neutral for beating, the weaver uses a finger or the edge of the shuttle to push the weft thread upward at the center of the warp, creating an arc or bubble above the fell. The height of the arc determines the extra weft length provided.

For balanced plain weave at standard sett, a bubble height of approximately one-quarter of the warp width is a commonly taught starting point: a 10-inch-wide warp needs a bubble approximately 2.5 inches tall above the fell. The precise height is calibrated by examining the selvedge angle after several picks: if the selvedge threads angle inward toward the fell, the bubble is too small. If the selvedge threads angle outward (a convex loop at the selvedge), the bubble is too large. A correctly-sized bubble produces a selvedge thread that exits the cloth at a 90-degree angle to the warp — perpendicular to the fell line.

Finer setts require relatively larger bubbles because more warp-thread crossings per inch of weft means more accumulated undulation length needed. A 10-dent heddle at full threading (20 epi) needs a larger bubble proportionally than a 10-dent heddle at half threading (10 epi) for the same warp width. Yarn diameter also affects the required bubble height: thicker yarns produce larger vertical displacements at each crossing and require more extra weft length.

For Patreon pattern documentation, the bubble technique must be specified as a fraction of warp width or in inches for the project's actual warp width and sett. Instructions that say only "leave some slack" or "don't pull the weft too tight" are not actionable — the patron has no calibration target. A specification of "bubble height approximately 2 inches for a 10-inch warp" at the project's sett and yarn gives the patron a starting point they can adjust by observing selvedge angle.

The Apple Tax for rigid heddle weaving creators on Patreon

Rigid heddle weaving has become one of the fastest-growing craft audiences on YouTube and Pinterest over the last several years. The accessible entry point — a quality rigid heddle loom costs $150–$400, compared to several thousand dollars for a floor loom — means the audience skews toward new craft learners who discover the practice through recommendation algorithms on mobile devices. Mobile-dominant discovery patterns produce a high iOS proportion in the audience.

Audience iOS proportions for rigid heddle weaving content: YouTube rigid heddle weaving tutorial channels 58–72% iOS; Instagram rigid heddle weaving project content 70–82% iOS; Pinterest rigid heddle weaving boards and pattern saves 72–84% iOS; Facebook rigid heddle weaving community groups 60–72% iOS.

Rigid heddle instructors on Patreon offer pattern downloads, project plans, pick-up stick charts, warping guides, and technique deep-dives as patron rewards. Monthly revenue for active rigid heddle instructors with established programs ranges from approximately $150 to $800 per month. The median active instructor in the $250–$400 range is the most common case.

At $150 per month with 70% iOS (YouTube-primary creator): $150 × 0.70 × 0.30 = $31.50 per month, $378 per year — diverted from creator income to Apple beginning November 1, 2026.

At $300 per month with 73% iOS (mixed platform creator with active Instagram and YouTube): $300 × 0.73 × 0.30 = $65.70 per month, $788.40 per year.

At $500 per month with 76% iOS (established instructor with Pinterest-heavy audience and full pattern library): $500 × 0.76 × 0.30 = $114 per month, $1,368 per year.

The mechanism of the loss: Apple's in-app purchase (IAP) policy requires that any digital subscription sold through an iOS app must use Apple's IAP system, which charges a 30% commission on each transaction. Patreon's iOS app processes patron subscriptions through Apple IAP. From November 1, 2026, Patreon will pass this 30% cost to creators rather than absorbing it. Every iOS-subscribed patron generates a 30% fee on their pledge amount, paid by the creator.

The fix requires no technical work and no platform migration. Apple's IAP fee applies only to subscriptions processed through the iOS app. A patron who subscribes to a Patreon page through a web browser — on any device, including an iPhone or iPad — does not use the iOS app checkout and does not trigger the IAP fee. That patron can subsequently access Patreon content through the iOS app without any fee consequence; the fee applies at subscription time, not at content access time.

The creator's action: direct all potential new patrons to the Patreon page URL in a browser, not to the Patreon app. Add a visible note to the Patreon page ("Join from a browser for the best value — joining through the Patreon iOS app adds a fee that comes from my income"). Communicate to existing iOS-subscribed patrons: identify the specific dollar amount that will divert to Apple on November 1 from their subscription, ask them to cancel their current iOS subscription and re-subscribe through the web browser. The dollar-amount framing is more motivating than an abstract policy description. A patron paying $10 per month who subscribes via iOS will send $3 per month to Apple — $36 per year — starting November 1.

KeepTier provides a hosted web-only checkout page at your own domain that handles this transparently: the page is web-only by design, with no iOS app to trigger an IAP fee, a Stripe Checkout integration for direct subscription processing, and messaging that explains to patrons why the web checkout protects the creator's income.

The deadline is November 1, 2026. The communication to existing iOS patrons needs to happen with enough lead time for patrons to cancel their app subscription at the end of their current billing cycle and re-subscribe via browser before the next billing date. For a patron with a monthly subscription renewing October 15, the window to act before the November 1 cutover is approximately 16 days after receiving the message. The communication should go out in September 2026 to allow all patrons sufficient lead time regardless of their billing cycle date.